Mahopac Homes with Oil Heating

Welcome to Mahopac, NY – a charming community nestled in the scenic beauty of Putnam County. Known for its picturesque landscapes and vibrant local culture, Mahopac is not just a place to live; it’s a place to thrive.

One of the standout features of this area is the highly regarded Mahopac Central School District, which is dedicated to providing quality education and fostering a nurturing environment for students. With a commitment to academic excellence, the district boasts a range of programs designed to cater to diverse learning styles and interests. Parents can take comfort in knowing that their children will receive a well-rounded education, supported by dedicated educators and a strong community involvement.

Beyond its educational offerings, Mahopac is also known for its warm, welcoming neighborhoods, where homes with oil heating can provide a cozy and efficient living experience. Many of these residences feature classic designs that blend seamlessly with the natural surroundings, offering not just a house, but a true home. With oil heating, residents enjoy reliable warmth during the chilly New York winters, making these homes both practical and inviting.

Whether you’re exploring the local parks, enjoying the serene lakes, or engaging in community events, Mahopac is a place where families can create lasting memories. With its excellent school district and charming homes, Mahopac is truly a hidden gem in Putnam County, waiting for you to discover its unique charm and vibrant lifestyle. Come and experience the warmth of Mahopac – your ideal home awaits!

Newest Mahopac Homes with Oil Heating

$1,400,000

1040196 MLS

INVESTORS TAKE NOTICE! Rare opportunity to own a six-unit multifamily property consisting of two separate buildings, offering approximately 5,870 square feet on .44 acres with parking for approximately 15 cars. With five of the six apartments updated, this property offers an exceptional combination of current income, attractive unit mix, and long-term investment potential. The two-building configuration includes four apartments at 174 Myrtle Avenue and two apartments at 176 Myrtle Avenue, providing flexibility and diversification within one investment. The unit mix includes two-, three-, and four-bedroom apartments, appealing to a broad range of tenants. With substantial updating already completed, ample off-street parking, six income-producing units, and strong in-place rental income, this is an opportunity for an investor to acquire a sizable multifamily asset with income from day one and potential for future upside. Whether you're expanding an existing portfolio or looking for your next investment property, this unique two-building, six-unit offering deserves a closer look.

174-176 Myrtle Avenue, Mahopac

$699,000

5 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1040487 MLS

Set on a beautiful private property in Mahopac, this impressive 5-bedroom, 3-bath residence offers over 3,000 square feet of thoughtfully designed living space, an inviting floor plan, and an exceptional backyard ideal for entertaining and everyday enjoyment. The main level features a bright and welcoming living room with fireplace, hardwood floors, and a generous bay window. The updated kitchen combines style and functionality with abundant cabinetry, granite countertops, stainless steel appliances, and a comfortable dining area. The adjoining dining room is a true focal point, showcasing soaring vaulted ceilings, exposed beams, skylights, and walls of windows overlooking the lush grounds, creating a wonderful sense of space while bringing the outdoors in. The flexible floor plan provides ample room for entertaining, working from home, and comfortable everyday living. The lower level offers exceptional versatility with a well-appointed in-law suite featuring its own living area, kitchenette, bedrooms, and full bath—ideal for extended family, guests, or multi-generational living. Outside, the property takes on a resort-like feel. The in-ground pool is surrounded by an expansive patio with ample space for lounging, dining, and entertaining, while the private, level yard provides plenty of room for recreation, gardening, and outdoor activities. Multiple gathering areas create a natural extension of the home's living space and make it easy to enjoy the property throughout the warmer months. Offering generous proportions, a flexible layout, quality updates, and an exceptional outdoor setting, this Mahopac residence delivers the perfect balance of comfort, privacy, and versatility.

41 Fenwood Road, Mahopac

$529,000

4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1041331 MLS

Very desirable, expandable 4 Bedroom Cape in the Mahopac School District. Well maintained in a quiet neighborhood on a Cul de Sac shared with only 2 other homes. The property borders a horse farm and is in close proximity to the West Branch Reservoir with seasonal reservoir and farm views. The home features 4 BR's, 2 Baths, hardwood floors, masonry fireplace, new septic tank, recent oil burner and windows. Full Walk-Out basement (630 sq. ft. not incl in total sq. ft.) with slider's to a brick patio and large back yard. Great location and best 4 Bedroom value in the Mahopac CSD.

72 Ann Road, Carmel

$550,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1039266 MLS

Pay your taxes and more with this legally approved one bedroom accessory apartment with walk out in lower level. This home comes with lake rights to beautiful Lake Cassie for swimming, fishing boating and club house with no additional fee. Great brick faced house on over 3/4 of an acre with a roaring brook bordering the property. First floor has all redone hardwood floors. Large eat-in kitchen with door leading to deck. Floor to ceiling bay window in living room. Two bedrooms and an office complete the first floor. Lower level has legal one bedroom accessory apartment with open floor plan and great French doors leading to patio. Wood burning stove and tiled floor. Ample size two car garage. Close to Train, highways, shops, restaurants and bike path. Mahopac schools with Fulmar Road as the elementary.

184 Lake Drive, Mahopac

$525,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1040283 MLS

Charming, move-in-ready single-family home boasting three bedrooms and two full bathrooms. The bright and comfortable interior features high ceilings, a functional layout, two first-floor bedrooms, spacious family and living areas, and a sun-filled dining room surrounded by windows. The private second-floor primary bedroom includes an en-suite bathroom. Outside, enjoy a private yard and deck—perfect for relaxing, entertaining, and everyday enjoyment. Conveniently located near Lake Mahopac, downtown Mahopac, shopping, dining, schools, and local amenities. This well-maintained home offers comfort, convenience, and an excellent location. Enjoy Lake Mahopac access with fishing, boating, and plenty of outdoor recreation. A wonderful location for those who love lake activities, scenic views, and an active lifestyle, with so much to do close to home.

17 Mary Avenue, Mahopac

$595,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1039449 MLS

Fantastic country setting! Conveniently located, yet a private retreat to enjoy nature. Truly a unique property! Mahopac school district, Carmel P.O. Sunny, private 1930’s farmhouse colonial with sprawling, open lawn, set on almost 1.5 acres. Sit back and relax on your rocking chair front porch or sunny patio in the backyard. The main floor offers a sprawling family room with wood burning fireplace and french doors out to porch, formal dining room with french doors out to backyard and a fully renovated kitchen with breakfast nook area. Updated full bath on main floor, light and bright with large windows and wood flooring/tiling throughout. Two staircases to the second floor; featuring a very large primary suite, walk in closet, soaking tub, shower alcove and walk thru office. A second large bedroom and laundry room complete the upstairs. Walking distance to the bike trail! Route 6, shopping and dining are just around the corner, 5 miles to the Croton Falls Train. Live the Putnam County life of hiking trails, lake access, parks, community, farmers markets, concert series, outdoor movies and watch party events!

11 Crafts Road, Mahopac

$685,000

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1038286 MLS

Welcome to this beautifully updated 3-bedroom, 2.5-bath raised ranch, ideally situated in a great Mahopac neighborhood. The home features a bright and spacious open-concept layout with hardwood floors throughout and tons of natural light. The renovated kitchen offers stainless steel appliances, modern countertops, a large center island, and direct access to the deck—perfect for entertaining and outdoor dining. The main level also features a spacious living room, three generously sized bedrooms, an updated full bathroom, and a primary bedroom with its own modern en-suite bath. Downstairs, you'll find a fully finished lower level offering additional living space along with a den or home office, half bath, and access to the 2-car garage. Outside, enjoy a large brick patio, deck, and plenty of driveway parking, providing multiple spaces for hosting and relaxing. Conveniently located near major highways for an easy commute, this move-in-ready home offers the perfect combination of modern updates, space, and convenience.

161 Geymer Drive, Mahopac

$710,000

4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1038376 MLS

Fall in love with this spacious, updated Mahopac home! Offering 3 comfortable bedrooms, 2 full baths, and an attached garage, this property has all the room you need to grow. The heart of the home features a warm fireplace and seamless flow, extending down to a massive finished lower level. Step outside to enjoy your private 0.54-acre yard, ideal for weekend BBQs or quiet mornings. Enjoy independent living with your own private well and updated septic system. Located in a peaceful neighborhood just minutes from local schools, shopping, and recreation. Don't miss this one!

65 Plum Road, Mahopac

$300,000

1036114 MLS ⋅ The Old Stone Building BLDG.

Prime first-floor professional office condo in the historic Old Stone Building in Mahopac. This well-maintained suite features two private entrances, two bathrooms, and a versatile layout suited for a wide range of professional uses. At present, the unit functions as a single professional office suite. However, the floor plan offers the flexibility to be reconfigured into two independent office spaces should future requirements call for it. This property is part of a small five-unit office condominium, where the owners have established a monthly fee to maintain the building, covering routine upkeep and shared operating expenses. In addition, the owners collectively split the cost of any major repairs, ensuring the building remains well cared for and professionally managed. The condo is currently leased to a long-term, reliable tenant who wishes to remain, providing immediate stability and income for an investor or owner-occupant. A rare opportunity to own a flexible, income-producing professional space in one of Mahopac’s most recognizable buildings.

21 Clark Place Unit #1A, Mahopac

$549,000

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1036020 MLS

Welcome to this beautifully maintained ranch in Carmel, where comfort, convenience, and everyday functionality come together. The bright eat-in kitchen has been tastefully updated with quartz countertops, a tile backsplash, and abundant cabinetry, while hardwood floors flow throughout the main level. The inviting living room features a cozy wood-burning fireplace and an oversized picture window that fills the space with natural light and overlooks the beautifully landscaped front yard. The lower level offers versatile bonus space ideal for hobbies, fitness, a workshop, or other lifestyle needs. Situated on over a quarter acre, the fully fenced backyard is surrounded by mature trees and offers an abundance of green space for entertaining, relaxing, gardening, or play. An attached one-car garage, an oversized driveway with parking for multiple vehicles, and a Level 2 EV charger provide added convenience for today's lifestyle. Located in the Mahopac Central School District and just minutes from the Croton Falls Metro-North station and Route 684, this home offers an easy commute to NYC while enjoying the privacy and charm of suburban living. This home truly checks all the boxes—move right in and make it your own.

707 Croton Falls Road, Carmel

$599,900

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1035678 MLS

Beautifully renovated raised ranch located in the Mahopac School District, offering a move-in ready home with modern updates throughout. The bright and spacious living room features a stunning bow window that fills the space with natural light. The updated eat-in kitchen showcases granite countertops, beautiful cabinetry, a newer center island, and sliding glass doors leading to a spacious Trex deck overlooking the level backyard. Hardwood floors run throughout the main level, which includes a spacious primary bedroom with an updated half bath, two additional bedrooms, and a beautiful full hall bathroom. The bright lower level offers a family room, office, large laundry and utility room with abundant storage, as well as direct access to the attached garage featuring an updated above-ground oil tank. The generously sized backyard extends into the wooded area to the right, providing additional privacy and a peaceful natural setting. As an added bonus, enjoy lake rights to Lake Casse, where residents have access to a private beach and playground, providing the perfect place to relax, swim, and enjoy the outdoors.

128 Shear Hill Road, Mahopac

$1,598,000

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1032241 MLS

Live on vacation every day! Summer and the beauty of all the seasons awaits, only an hour from NYC. Set along one of Kirk Lake’s most secluded stretches, this exceptional waterfront property offers a rare blend of privacy, breathtaking views, and glorious lakeside living. Gorgeous views from almost every room, and from deck, balcony, yard, patio, hot tub, additional lakeside deck, and your private dock. Forever green (unbuildable) lakefront across assures the same vista for years to come. Thoughtfully renovated and redesigned to maximize the setting, the home captures sweeping lake views throughout and delivers a rare combination of privacy, refined indoor-outdoor living and the ultimate in recreation/lake life. Additional separate lot (10 Lakeside) included, with yard and parking for 10 plus cars, plus room for a garage/additional space for potential office/studio/ADU/whatever you need. One of a kind, perfect for entertaining and making magical memories. Watch moonlight over the lake, take a midnight dip, learn to waterski - the options for fun are endless. From boating and swimming to kayaking, paddleboarding, fishing, and waterskiing, the property offers direct access to an active waterfront lifestyle with a more peaceful and private locale than that of the other lakes nearby (adjacent to Lake Mahopac). Room for all your watersports toys (and those in the photos can be included - kayaks, paddleboards, paddleboat, canoe!) plus a shed for storage. Extensive renovations over $250k include: 2009 Major renovation/expansion of home -New Trex deck, Trex dock, roof, furnace, Unilock and bluestone walkways, electrical upgrade, hydro air high energy efficiency system, 2009 Kitchen remodel - GE Profile and Trivection ovens, granite counters, stainless, laundry in lower level and machines/hookup in mudroom, 2013 Hot tub, 2019 New refrigerator, 2023 Lower level renovation , additional refrigerators, 2024 New well pump, 2024 New water heater, 2024 New sleeve under road when road was repaved (for ease of future utility modification), 2025 New dishwasher & microwave, Custom tiles in kitchen and bathroom made by Rosanne Breuer, Master Potter. Custom walk in closet in primary BR. Private West Kirk Lake Civic Association Beach down the street with swimming area, park and picnic tables for approx. $200 annual membership. Red Mills Historic Park adjacent, 3.4 miles from the Taconic, 2.4 miles from the North County Trail and 1 mile from Putnam National Golf course. Don't miss this rare opportunity to live on Kirk Lake, the best kept secret of the Lakes District. IYKYK! Taxes with STAR savings approximately $17,671. (Adjacent Lot Taxes, Lot size Acres and Lot size sq.ft. included in listing)

11 Lakeside Road, Mahopac

Start Your Search

Listings courtesy of OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID. Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of . All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker or MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information.